Print

Print


Hello,

I've recently started using ECJ and MASON to create a neuroevolution program and I really appreciate the work put into both.  However, when doing some debugging I attempted to read in an individual for a subpopulation and encountered a few problems:

1) When Subpopulation.setup() first creates the array of individuals each individual is null.  This isn't a problem when creating new individuals, but when reading on line 270 Subpopulation.readSubpopulation() first checks to see if the individual in the individual array is null which it's always going to be.  So instead of reading in the individual it will always create new individuals.  It appears that this check was done to avoid an invalid element error since readIndividual() is an instance function.  A dummy individual seems like the easiest way to fix this issue.

2) Even after this fix though there is still a problem if the individual has a custom printIndividual() method (for instance, if the class is a child of Individual with additional information that is printed and needs to be read in).  It would be necessary then to create a dummy individual that is the same type of individual specified in the subpop's species before calling readIndividual() on it.

3) Tutorial 3 should be updated to reflect the changes to printSubpopulation() and readSubpopulation() that include the number of individuals and individual index preambles.

I believe for my purposes that I'll simply create a child of Subpopulation to correct the above issues.  However, I wanted to bring it to your attention for future releases or if I've missed something and I'm not doing something correctly.

Thank you,

Myron Tuttle